Skip to main content

What was the most confusing Thanksgiving the U.S. ever had—and why do we eat turkey on Thanksgiving?

Oct 31, 2014 12:54PM ● Published by Charles Reichblum

In 1939, President Franklin Roosevelt thought he had a great idea. To help the nation’s economy, he said it would be good to advance Thanksgiving from its traditional fourth Thursday of November to the third Thursday of the month in order to start the Christmas shopping season earlier and make for a longer holiday shopping season.

So Roosevelt issued a proclamation changing the date of Thanksgiving, but there was just one problem: 24 of the then 48 states accepted Roosevelt’s proclamation, but the other 24 didn’t, and kept the holiday on the fourth Thursday. There was confusion around the nation—half of the states had Thanksgiving on the third Thursday of November and the other half had it on the fourth Thursday. If you wanted to visit Grandma in another state on Thanksgiving weekend, you had to check and make sure her Thanksgiving was the same as yours. If it wasn’t, either you left on your Thanksgiving and visited her on her non-holiday weekend, or you left on your non-holiday to be with her during her Thanksgiving.

Merchants, the national media—and just about everybody—was confused across the nation. Travel plans and work days were all mixed up. Roosevelt abandoned his idea the next year and then Congress made it official when it passed a law declaring that from then on, Thanksgiving would ALWAYS be on the fourth Thursday of November for the whole country.

So when we all sit down to dinner on that day, why do we eat turkey? Would you believe that at the first Thanksgiving dinners with the Pilgrims, they did not eat turkey, according to many historians? These scholars say that it’s more likely that the Pilgrims at those first Thanksgivings ate venison, goose, duck and fish.

The idea of turkey at Thanksgiving began in the 1860s when President Abraham Lincoln was the first president to declare Thanksgiving a regular, annual national holiday. Turkey gradually became the traditional Thanksgiving fare, helped by the abundance of turkeys then in many parts of America and the custom at that time of cooking turkeys for special occasions.

(Dr. Knowledge is heard on KDKA and the CBS radio network with his “Knowledge in a Nutshell” feature, and is author of the “Knowledge in a Nutshell” and “Dr. Knowledge Presents…” book series).

Today President Roosevelt Thanksgiving turkey
  • 2018 Lucky Number


    The Sisters of Divine Providence are pleased to announce the availability of the 2018 Lucky Numbe...

  • Family Volunteer Days

    10:00AM — 12:00PM

    Global Links, a Pittsburgh-based humanitarian aid organization, has always valued children as cap...

  • Orchard Hill Church December events

    10:00AM — 10:00PM

    North Happenings: Christmas Eve at Orchard Hill Be a part of this wonderful family celebratio...

  • Phipps’ Holiday Magic! Winter Flower Show and Light Garden is magical, bigger and better than eve...

  • A limited run of the National Aviary’s new free-flight bird show Bird Brains opened with a stella...

  • I Made It! Market

    11:00AM — 05:00PM

    — I Made It! Market, Pittsburgh’s nomadic indie craft marketplace, is traveling to the North Hill...

  • Ring Pittsburgh concerts


    Ring Pittsburgh, your community handbell choir, cordially invites you to join us at our holiday p...

  • Saturdays Singles Dance

    07:00PM — 12:00AM

    For ages 40+. Saturday, December 2nd, Free Speed Dating & Free Nacho Bar! Free, optional ice-br...








Receive a digital edition of NHM in your inbox every month. Sign up by sending a request to